The Problem with Being Independent

In the fall of 2000, Destiny's Child debuted their third hit single: Independent Women. It was a rallying cry for women to be 50/50 in relationships, depend on themselves, and that you only needed a man when you were lonely (and even then he was dismissible).

I can remember thinking. That's right, Beyonce! Sing it, girl (insert fist pumping).

But 14 years later, being married, and two months into interviewing christian, black, men...I can see how the mindset of independence can be damaging to healthy relationships.

Independence is a barrier to healthy relationships 

Two of the guys I talked to this week explained that independence and control are barriers that keep us from being in healthy relationships. Independence allows us to protect ourselves if something goes wrong. We'll be okay if a man leaves us, or if he messes up, because we didn't really need him in the first place. So, we metaphorically keep our bags packed and are always ready to make a quick exit.  Another guy explained that when we convince ourselves we don't need a man, it affects how we treat them.

Independence is about protection

In her book, The Surrendered Single, Laura Doyle explains that women often protect themselves from disappointment and vulnerability by flaunting their independence. She says that strength is attractive, but hard-nosed independence sends a "get away" message. Women have another side that is soft and vulnerable. That is what men are drawn to. For instance, when you let a man treat you to dinner or help you with your luggage. You give him the opportunity to demonstrate his generosity. This makes him feel proud and happy. If you dismiss his offers in the name of independence, you reject him. 

God created men to be rescuers. 

In his book, Wild at Heart, John Eldredge explains that the very essence of the way that God created man is to rescue a beauty. From the ancient fables to the latest blockbuster, the theme of a strong man coming to rescue a beautiful woman is universal to human nature. It is written in our hearts, one of the core desires of every man and woman. Moses came to the aid of Zipporah and her sisters at the well.  Boaz came to the aid of Ruth and Naomi. And, Joseph saved Mary from being stoned because of the immaculate conception.

So, the next time a man wants to come to your rescue, buy you dinner, or help you stuff your oversized carry-on in the overhead bin...resist the desire to assert your independence and allow him to be the man that God has created him to be.